Major League Soccer
Yankee Stadium
Finished 3 - 1 (FT)
(HT: 1 - 1)
| New York City |
| 1 | Sean Johnson |
| 2 | Boris Sekulic |
| 3 | Anton Tinnerholm |
| 3 | Jonathan Bornstein |
| 4 | Maxime Chanot |
| 5 | Francisco Calvo |
| 6 | Alexander Callens |
| 6 | Miguel Navarro |
| 7 | Ignacio Aliseda |
| 8 | Alexander Ring |
| 9 | Heber |
| 10 | Maxi Moralez |
| 10 | Alvaro Medran |
| 11 | Przemyslaw Frankowski |
| 11 | Valentin Castellanos |
| 13 | Brandt Bronico |
| 14 | Djordje Mihailovic |
| 15 | Tony Rocha |
| 16 | Mike Azira |
| 16 | James Sands |
| 17 | Gary Mackay Steven |
| 19 | Jesus Medina |
| 20 | Wyatt Omsberg |
| 20 | Gudmundur Thorarinsson |
| 21 | Fabian Herbers |
| 22 | Mauricio Pineda |
| 22 | Ronald Matarrita |
| 24 | Connor Sparrow |
| 25 | Nicholas Slonina |
| 25 | Joe Scally |
| 26 | Nicolas Acevedo |
| 27 | Robert Beric |
| 28 | Alexandru Mitrita |
| 28 | Elliot Collier |
| 29 | Ismael Tajouri |
| 30 | Gaston Gimenez |
| 32 | Gabriel Slonina |
| 36 | Andre Reynolds II |
| 40 | Brian Gutierrez |
| 41 | Brad Stuver |
| 55 | Keaton Parks |